LA CROSSE, Wis. – The No. 21-ranked Carleton College women's soccer team saw its postseason run end with a 2-1 (2OT) loss at No. 15 University of Wisconsin-La Crosse in the second round of the NCAA Championship.
UW-La Crosse (22-1-0) grabbed the early lead, but Carleton's (14-2-3)
Lola Feurer tallied the equalizer late in regulation.
"I knew if we could stay organized, commit to more possession-based style and connect a bunch of passes, eventually we'd break them down, and we did," said Carleton head coach
Jessica Mueller. "It was really exciting because we earned the goal to keep us in the game. It was a fun competitive game; we knew it would be."
Midway through the second overtime period, the Eagles were awarded a penalty kick, which they converted to advance to the third round.
The loss snapped a program-record 17-game unbeaten streak for Carleton whose only other setback came in a season opening 1-0 defeat at North Central College. The Knights finished the season with a .816 win percentage, second-highest in program annals (see chart below).
The Knights had the contest's first scoring chance when UW-La Crosse goalkeeper Summer Nicolai bobbled a cross into by box by
Lily Shure, but the Eagles' netminder was able to fall on the loose ball right before
Lauren Caldwell could get a toe on it.
UW-La Crosse, which entered the night ranked fifth in the nation in scoring at 3.82 goals per game, took the lead in the 12th minute. A steal in the midfield sparked a counterattack that concluded with Jillian Sawadski's one-touch volley goal—her 10th tally of the season.
Carleton, which had trailed for less than three minutes total since the season opener, found itself in unfamiliar territory. But the Knights weathered the storm and used sustain pressure to finally crack the Eagles' defense—which was third stingiest in the country—in the 87th minute. Centerback
Zaraya Jordan sent the ball into the box, Feurer took a touch and shot across the goal for her sixth goal of the season.
"We believed it the whole time," said Feurer. "It was a matter of time before we got one in. We stayed composed; we didn't panic. I had a little bit of a window and watched it go in the back of the net in slow motion."
UW-La Crosse immediately went on the attack and forced Carleton goalkeeper
Avery Trapp to make a leaping save, tipping the ball over the crossbar in the 88th minute. Following the ensuing corner kick, Jordan was forced to clear a header off the line to keep the score deadlocked.
Neither team scored in the first 10-minute overtime period.
Isabelle Connolly came closest, when her shot midway through the opening extra period clanged off the outside of the left post.
Trapp, who finished with nine saves—her highest total since the season opener—made several quality stops on the night and was perfectly positioned to corral a UWL header in the 103rd minute.
A little over minute later, an Eagle went down in the box, and the official gave the hosts a penalty kick. Sera Speltz deposited the spot kick into the left side of the net, sending UW-La Crosse onto the third round.
UWL totaled 25 shots in the game, 12 of them on goal. Carleton attempted 12 shots, seven of which were on frame, resulting in six saves for Nicolai. The Eagles took nine corner kicks compared to two for the Knights.
"I couldn't be more proud of this team," said Mueller. "Our goal with under three minutes left in regulation was truly indicative of our culture and our season. This is the hardest working team I've ever coached. They never quit. These strong, determined young women have trained and competed with so much grit and joy all season long and it's been a privilege to be their coach. I cannot wait to see what our seniors do next, beyond their time at Carleton. They are going to make an incredible impact. What a special group!"
Longest Unbeaten Streaks in Team History
17 games — (14-0-3) — Sept. 11-Nov. 14, 2026
16 games — (14-0-2) — Sept. 11-Nov. 12, 2010
16 games — (14-0-2) — Sept. 9-Nov. 2, 2023
14 games — (11-0-3) — Sept. 10-Nov. 2, 2022
Highest Win Percentage in Team History
.824 — (14-3-0) — 1982
.816 — (14-2-3) — 2026
.813 — (18-3-3) — 2025
.810 — (16-3-2) — 2023
.806 — (13-2-3) — 2022
.800 — (15-3-2) — 2010